JD Gator 550 s4 vs Polaris Ranger crew 500
dba fido
9:33p, 06/05/12
dba fido
8676 posts, joined 09/26/2010
Looking to buy my first UTV and going to check them out tomorrow. Online it looks like the Polaris is the way to go. Any reason I'd be better off with the Gator?
AZAG08
9:43p, 06/05/12
AZAG08
2950 posts, joined 10/19/2009
No experience with Polaris but we have a gator and have no complaints. We like it a lot

[This message has been edited by AZAG08 (edited 6/5/2012 9:44p).]
TAMU77CLAY
10:31p, 06/05/12
TAMU77CLAY
279 posts, joined 10/03/2002
Polaris hands down no question. Better suspension and ride. Had 2 gators before discovering polaris and they are superior to gators by a bunch.
big ben
10:52p, 06/05/12
big ben
7409 posts, joined 05/09/2007
We had a brand new Ranger 500 EFI out on the property we hunt and traded it in after two seasons because we had numerous idling issues, starting issues, problems getting the vehicle in gear, etc.

Traded for a Kawasaki Mule and are much happier. This doesn't exactly help your comparison but just an FYI.

EDIT: I would also look at Kubota, we have one on our jobsite that gets abused on a daily basis by our field hands and has continued to work without any issues.

[This message has been edited by big ben (edited 6/5/2012 10:53p).]
sixbarag
11:14p, 06/05/12
sixbarag
492 posts, joined 12/11/2006
Had the 500 crew for 1 1/2 years now it is far better ride and drive than the Mule I've had for 8 years. Not sure bout gator but would look at HP and ride. Polaris has been top notch for years and I don't see JD passing them up in the UTV market that easily. And that's coming from a guy who owns nothing but JD tractors, implements and lawn equipment.
EskimoJoe
8:33a, 06/06/12
EskimoJoe
440 posts, joined 10/28/2010
Kubota RTV diesel series. They make the gators, mules, and rangers look like a honda civic compared to a 1 ton truck.

(assuming budget is of no concern)
WestTexAG
8:56a, 06/06/12
WestTexAG
2489 posts, joined 09/27/2004
quote:
Kubota RTV diesel series. They make the gators, mules, and rangers look like a honda civic compared to a 1 ton truck.

(assuming budget is of no concern)

Except the overheating issue they have. They are hosses when running right, but it's easier than it should be to blow the motor.
Na Zdraví 87
9:01a, 06/06/12
Na Zdraví 87
12371 posts, joined 10/21/1999
I have the Gator 550 s4 and love it. That thing rides so smooth going across the pasture. Does everything I need it to do. And it has a lot of extras you can add on.
FishrCoAg
9:28a, 06/06/12
FishrCoAg
1541 posts, joined 10/12/2000
To complicate things further, look at the Honda Big Red as well. They make them in green & camo now.
Centerpole90
10:07a, 06/06/12
Centerpole90
4797 posts, joined 12/12/2003
quote:
No experience with Gator but we have a Ranger 800 and have no complaints. We like it a lot

FIFY. All that aside I'm sure they are both quality rigs.
DVM97
10:34a, 06/06/12
DVM97
4947 posts, joined 10/11/1999
My Ranger 500 is awesome, love everything it does, rides smooth, great power, great speed. I'm not sure how fast a Deere goes, but I bet it's not close to what a Ranger will do.


DVM
Coufal-Prater
10:46a, 06/06/12
Coufal-Prater
75 posts, joined 08/05/2011
Traditionally, John Deere made Gators specially for farm work. In 2010, they released the 825i, and the new line of XUV was born.

I have driven all of our UTVs, as well as most of our competitors. In my opinion, the suspension design delivers the smoothest ride available. The longer wheelbase of the 550 makes it even smoother. Many of the specs are shared between the two machines, or are fairly close. One feature that people really seem to like on the 550 S4, is the ability to fold the back seat flat, and use it as an extended cargo box. I honestly don’t know if the other machines can do this, I just know that I have had many conversations with customers about the option.

All that being said, my advice is to drive both machines. I don’t know where you live, but our dealership will bring the equipment to you, and let you test drive the equipment at your place. Or, at our Bryan location, we have a course designed with lots of obstacles to test the ride, traction, and durability. If nothing else, it is fun to take a ride and get a little muddy! Also, our dealerships have some demo units available right now that include full warranty and discounted based on the number of hours on the machine- so you can get a pretty good deal.

As always, make sure that you are comfortable with the dealership, and the service department. It is a big purchase, and one that should bring you a lot of enjoyment!



Sponsor Message: Coufal-Prater Equipment – Quality and Integrity at Prices You Can Afford!
Na Zdraví 87
11:57a, 06/06/12
Na Zdraví 87
12371 posts, joined 10/21/1999
And I bought mine at Coufal-Prater in Taylor!
dba fido
12:16p, 06/06/12
dba fido
8676 posts, joined 09/26/2010
Just left the JD dealership. The sales rep couldn't get the demo 550 to start. Think I'll be getting the Ranger with EFI
BMach
12:24p, 06/06/12
BMach
1271 posts, joined 07/24/2006
+1 for the Polaris, there is a reason why they are number 1 in UTV sales year in and year out.
(Page 1 of 1)
Watchlist Add Reply New Topic
Forums Premium Watchlist
Non-Mobile Version
Copyright ©2014 Maroon & White LP.
All rights reserved.
[ Log On ]