Make a new playoff rule
2,268 Views | 14 Replies
...
Muy
7:43a, 11/28/23
If you win your division with a .500 or worse record, you get a Wildcard spot.
redag06
8:34a, 11/28/23
You don't have a winning record, you don't get in to the playoffs whether you win the division or not.
boy09
9:10a, 11/28/23
It's only happened 3 times in the past 40 years. And 2 of those teams won a playoff game.

It's not that big of a deal. The NFL has way more important issues/rule changes to address imo.
redag06
10:11a, 11/28/23
In reply to boy09
3 times too many
W
10:16a, 11/28/23
Patrick Mahomes must play in at least one road playoff game

incredible that he still hasn't
birdman
12:39p, 11/28/23
No reseeding after each round. Set up the bracket before playoffs and stick with it.
MookieBlaylock
1:10p, 11/28/23
In season tournaments def the new rule
GrapevineAg
9:03p, 11/28/23
Make it, take it: you score a TD, they kickoff to you.
EliteZags
4:49p, 11/29/23
no kickers
justnobody79
2:42p, 11/30/23
If there is a division winner with a less than .500 record they don't make the playoffs, Wildcard #1 takes the sub .500 division winner's #4 seed. The team with the next best record backfills the wildcard spot.
MookieBlaylock
6:20p, 1/7/24
This terrible thread aged well
LincolnBorglum79
10:06p, 1/7/24
The rules are fine as is. If you win the division at 8-9 you still deserve to host the best wildcard. 2/3's of the time the team with the worst record won. I think the bye for the 1 seed will die first as soon as a 1 seed loses their first game due to the week off.
LincolnBorglum79
10:10p, 1/7/24
How about a rule that an undefeated ACC champ is automatic over a 1 loss big 12 team? Or a rule that a 1 loss sec team automatically makes the final 4 over a big 10 team that only played 5 games. In a Covid year of course. The Texas Aggies get a shot at the 2020 title and FSU gets to lose badly to washington
AustinAg2K
2:41p, 1/8/24
In reply to LincolnBorglum79
LincolnBorglum79 said:

How about a rule that an undefeated ACC champ is automatic over a 1 loss big 12 team? Or a rule that a 1 loss sec team automatically makes the final 4 over a big 10 team that only played 5 games. In a Covid year of course. The Texas Aggies get a shot at the 2020 title and FSU gets to lose badly to washington
The NFL should definitely make this rule...
GoAgs92
11:43a, 1/9/24
reseeding is horse crap!



CLOSE
×
Cancel
Copy Topic Link to Clipboard
Back
Copy
Page 1 of 1
Post Reply
×
Verify your student status Register
See Membership Benefits >
CLOSE
×
Night mode
Off
Auto-detect device settings
Off