Russia/Ukraine from Another Perspective (Relaunch Part Deux)
329,847 Views | 7791 Replies
...
Ag with kids
10:41a, 5/7/24
In reply to PlaneCrashGuy
PlaneCrashGuy said:

Teslag said:

The forced Ukrainian conscription videos are always fun when you read the comments. Almost every single time it's some old video, from various places around the world, showing something completely different. I remember one of them was a guy "jumping from his balcony to avoid conscription". Turns out it was a guy that had just murdered someone in south america and was trying to escape police.


Its pretty gross to find humans forced into sacrifice on the front line "fun"
Luckily, none of these videos show that...
FJB24
10:53a, 5/7/24
In reply to Ag with kids
The Hungarians don't want to participate in sending young men to certain death in the Biden-Nuland war. Weird.
Moderator
Staff
12:21p, 5/16/24
Alright, we will try this again after ANOTHER BREAK. All of the same things that locked this thread down around the close of the first 100 pages were the exact same issues happening in the last 100 pages. So we will just repost our message from Page 96 right here again. In that message we did make the threat that if this gets locked again it likely does not get relaunched. We do think the subject is important to talk about, so we are going to launch this again because we beleive our community needs to have the opportunity to debate and discuss. Everyone needs to do their part is discussing and debating this topic in GOOD FAITH. The mod team will not be that gracious in our actions against all the usual worst offenders on this thread. This is your warning.

PAGE 96 MESSAGE

We understand the need for an ongoing thread about the Russia-Ukraine conflict from a foreign/public/financial policy perspective vs. the long running thread discussing military strategy/tactics within the combat zones.

Hopefully a two week lock on this thread has served as an appropriate warning and break for everyone that has contributed in the correct ways on this thread and those that crossed lines.

Remember to respect all users when addressing them, regardless of differences in opinion on this subject.

If you are going to post statements based on opinion or information gleaned from other sources, please make this clear. When posting information from sources, post that source for others to read at least initially and make you subsequent posts your own take and/or summary of the information initially sourced.

It's not acceptable to call or infer another user is a propagandist. If you are going to argue that specific information is propaganda, you need to address the information directly with an explanation on what specifically makes the information incorrect or propaganda. Just making a "drive-by" statement that something is propaganda is not enough. You can expect those posts to be taken down and action taken against your account.

Charging users with the term troll or trolling will be considered thread derails or moderation questions. Posting these statements turns the thread away from the subject and toward the users. If you beleive a user is trolling or breaking another posting policy, you can flag the post and email moderator@texags.com to ask for a review. Otherwise, ignore posts that you beleive are trolling and spend time continuing substantive discussions about this topic.

We DO NOT consider this thread a "pro-russia" thread and the other thread a "pro-ukraine" thread or vice-versa. That is not our moderating standard for these threads. The strategy/tactics thread should be seen as a thread where people can talk about what is being reported on from the "front lines" of the confict from a military perspective. We consider this thread to be the political, social, and cultural discussion about the conflict. We would consider this thread a broader discussion that will have a wider spectrum of opinions on the politics, history, cause of the conflict and what the U.S., Europe, and any other countries role in the conflict might be in the past, present, or future.

DO NOT mischaracterize other users positions on the subject. This is considered jamming the discussion and turns the thread away from the topic and becames a fight between users or groups of users over the mischaracterizations. These are thread derails. We will act against these types of posts and users. If these posts begin dominating the thread again we will shut this back down and likely it will be for good next time.

If you need a refresher on our expectations for this thread and all threads on this platform please review the user agreement: texags.com/terms
Teslag
12:59p, 5/16/24
In reply to Moderator
Can we also get a limit on the number of tweets in a post? The excessively long posts comprising mostly of embedded tweets without significant poster opinion on each can make the board very difficult to read.

[Offending posters have been warned about this. We will be enforcing this on the thread as best we can. As well as trolling, troll policing, disrespectful and condescending engagement, strawman arguments, nicknaming, ad hominems, etc, etc. All the things that shut this down the first two times. If it starts up again with the same amount of regularity, all of you regular contributors will face extensive time-off. Post in good faith or don't post at all. -Staff]
74OA
7:35p, 5/16/24
In reply to Teslag
Good luck with that. You know who continues to routinely gum up the conversation with multi tweet posts over on the other Ukraine thread.
nortex97
8:54p, 5/16/24
Howdy fam. BRICS keep rolling along I see. The two individual parties winning the most in this conflict, by far.



Clearly happy to celebrate xidens ongoing proxy misadventure.
GAC06
8:57p, 5/16/24
In reply to nortex97
Michael initiated the hug with Fredo
nortex97
6:48a, 5/17/24
Europe is the real party that is the victim of the sanctions regime, paying for escalated energy prices etc:



Although, Europe often doesn't take the sanctions particularly 'seriously:'



Some Europeans…have noticed though.



One definition of 'winning': Ukraine is already, again, demographically decimated due to the combination of pre-war demographics, the exodus/fleeing from the conscription of more than half their military age population, and 500K deaths in the war. This, as well as the utter unpopularity of the regime within what is left of Ukraine, is why they won't ever have elections again, even rigged ones.

FJB24
5:51p, 5/17/24
WTF?

Quote:

Putin keeps trying to warn the American Neocons that they are playing with World War III, which will be nuclear. They issued a Notice to Air Missions (NOTAM) that they will be firing missiles in a test just off the coast of northern California coast, thereby alerting pilots of Russian missile launches to LAND / IMPACT in the Oakland Air Route Traffic Control Center ((ARTCC). This will begin tomorrow and continue for 10 days. This is 300 miles offshore in international waters.

What Putin does not get is that our wonderful Neocons care nothing about the country, the people, and certainly not the economy. The Climate Change zealots in the White House agree with them and think reducing the population may be the only way to reach their NET ZERO target for CO2. He keeps warning is this what you really want? They do not back down and want war so bad they can taste it in their sleep.
FJB24
5:53p, 5/17/24
In reply to 74OA
74OA said:

Good luck with that. You know who continues to routinely gum up the conversation with multi tweet posts over on the other Ukraine thread.
Is 'gum up the conversation' a euphemism for 'doesn't celebrate Zelensky/Nuland/Biden in the glorious war of the destruction of Ukraine appropriately like I do?'
notex
6:08p, 5/17/24
Yes, this is 'weird.'



If China Joe, the proxy war commander, is on the take from Beijing it all makes sense.

The airspace closure off California doesn't sound like it is military related:

nortex97
8:02p, 5/17/24
'The real problem with holding presidential elections in Ukraine right now is that Ukrainians might vote to end the war.'

So, we are propping up a totalitarian regime, for 'reasons.'
Quote:

There's also a profound dishonesty at work here on the part of the Biden administration and the Zelensky government. For many years, Ukrainian elections pitted the pro-Russian eastern parts of the country against the European-leaning western parts, with the latter constantly accusing Moscow of meddling in the country's elections to keep Ukraine in Russia's orbit. Glance at a map of Ukraine's election results from 2004 or 2010, and it's easy to see the geographical-political divide in the country.

The Russian invasion has now taken many of those voters in the eastern parts of Ukraine out of the electoral equation. So why would Ukraine's current pro-Western leadership want to cancel elections until these pro-Russian areas are able to vote?

At the risk of sounding like a conspiracy theorist, allow me to suggest that maybe the insistence on "all Ukrainians" being able to vote is a cynical ploy to prevent elections from taking place in the near future. Maybe Zelensky knows that Ukrainians, if given the chance, would vote his regime out of office and pursue peace negotiations with Moscow that Zelensky's Western sponsors won't allow.
More at the link, as they say. All on point.
TheBonifaceOption
8:03p, 5/17/24
TRADUCTOR
9:37p, 5/17/24
In reply to nortex97
Such a deal though.
Ags4DaWin
10:31p, 5/17/24
In reply to nortex97
Unpossible.

I was told that Ukraine was willing to fight to the last man.

The truth is actually that western Ukraine and Eastern Ukraine have two very different allegiances. Western allies more with Europe

Eastern identifies more with Russia and has been a thorn in the side of western Ukraine ever since the US overthrew the Ukrainian government.

If they allowed peace talks then the two would split with the Eastern half willingly joining with Russia again as that is where most of their allegiances, family, and cultural ties lie.

But peace hurts the MIC's bottom line and takes away a money laundering playground.....so no peace.
AlaskanAg99
10:47p, 5/17/24
In reply to Ags4DaWin
Ever wonder why or how eastern Ukraine identified more with Russia?

Read about the Holomodor and Soviet repopulation.
Teslag
10:59p, 5/17/24
In reply to Ags4DaWin
Ags4DaWin said:

Unpossible.

I was told that Ukraine was willing to fight to the last man.

The truth is actually that western Ukraine and Eastern Ukraine have two very different allegiances. Western allies more with Europe

Eastern identifies more with Russia and has been a thorn in the side of western Ukraine ever since the US overthrew the Ukrainian government.

If they allowed peace talks then the two would split with the Eastern half willingly joining with Russia again as that is where most of their allegiances, family, and cultural ties lie.

But peace hurts the MIC's bottom line and takes away a money laundering playground.....so no peace.


Most of the "Russian" areas are already under Russia control. They could easily end this today along current lines if they wanted.
Ag with kids
11:18p, 5/17/24
In reply to Teslag
Teslag said:

Ags4DaWin said:

Unpossible.

I was told that Ukraine was willing to fight to the last man.

The truth is actually that western Ukraine and Eastern Ukraine have two very different allegiances. Western allies more with Europe

Eastern identifies more with Russia and has been a thorn in the side of western Ukraine ever since the US overthrew the Ukrainian government.

If they allowed peace talks then the two would split with the Eastern half willingly joining with Russia again as that is where most of their allegiances, family, and cultural ties lie.

But peace hurts the MIC's bottom line and takes away a money laundering playground.....so no peace.


Most of the "Russian" areas are already under Russia control. They could easily end this today along current lines if they wanted.
Bolded is the important part...
nortex97
5:21a
Sure, Russia could end the war, not sure why that trope is being repeated. It might not end the Ukrainian shelling of "Russian occupied" areas (Or terrorist strikes at Crimea) or Belgorod though. Xi Jinping, the real commander of the ongoing conflict on both sides, does not want the war to stop. It is benefitting China and spiking energy prices for Europe. Xiden will do his part and so will Putin on the other side.

Lovely signs Ukraine is winning:



Medvedev on the obvious ramifications/intent behind giving the Kiev regime longer range weapons: he's right, obviously.



Western/Zelensky values:



Teslag
8:18a
Quote:

If this continues, the guaranteed buffer zone will be somewhere on the border with Poland. Or even within Poland itself.



Oh boy. Medvedev still full of delusion after two years being completely unable to see what Russia is really is today. He still sees Russia as a world power.
YouBet
8:59a
In reply to AlaskanAg99
AlaskanAg99 said:

Ever wonder why or how eastern Ukraine identified more with Russia?

Read about the Holomodor and Soviet repopulation.


While true, it's water under the bridge at this point. The reasoning is irrelevant. If those people now want to be with Russia, then that's what they want. To deter them away from that would mean the west then has to do their own version of re-educating and/or re-populating the region.

A pointless exercise and not worth the resources, time, death and destruction to do it.
PlaneCrashGuy
12:21p


The war is also a demonstration of the critical importance of our 2nd amendment.

I heard it said on a podcast that Russia's taken more land during its recent push than Ukraine took during its summer offensive. Not entirely sure if its true and it is hard to quantify exactly, bur his point was that this is the most land that has changed hands at any point since the initial invasion. Can anyone definitely confirm or deny this?
CLOSE
×
Cancel
Copy Topic Link to Clipboard
Back
Copy
Page 223 of 223
Post Reply
×
Verify your student status Register
See Membership Benefits >
CLOSE
×
Night mode
Off
Auto-detect device settings
Off