In reply to I Like Mike
Kind of. The deferred money will be taxed by where he lives. Which probably won't be Cali
5:24p, 12/11/23
Brilliant. Can go live anywhere else and collect the rest of his $680 million and not pay cali tax on it.
Also though that cuts the value of his contact in half though assuming a 10% interest rate.
Also though that cuts the value of his contact in half though assuming a 10% interest rate.
5:42p, 12/11/23
Not sure he can avoid California taxes. California has gotten pretty aggressive trying to tax wealthy residents that leave the state.
5:51p, 12/11/23
In reply to themissinglink
Sure some politicians in Cali will ***** about it, but nothing they can do really
5:51p, 12/11/23
so he signs a 10-year deal (2024 through 2034) and he will be paid $68 Million per year from 2034 to 2043 (after his contract expires). What a wild contract. Who knows what contract valuations will look like that far out. It could workout in the short term, but long term, it could be disastrous for the Dodgers...and hopefully it is.
6:08p, 12/11/23
In reply to amercer
https://www.sambrotman.com/blog/california-exit-tax
The fact that his employer paying his salary is officed in the state and the $68 million per year is deferred for services rendered (mostly) in California will complicate his residency once he retires if he leaves the state.
There may have been some state tax considerations, but I think the structure is more meant to allow the Dodgers to be competitive and continue to spend on other players while he is there.
Oh, but they can try…amercer said:
Sure some politicians in Cali will ***** about it, but nothing they can do really
https://www.sambrotman.com/blog/california-exit-tax
The fact that his employer paying his salary is officed in the state and the $68 million per year is deferred for services rendered (mostly) in California will complicate his residency once he retires if he leaves the state.
There may have been some state tax considerations, but I think the structure is more meant to allow the Dodgers to be competitive and continue to spend on other players while he is there.
8:53a, 12/12/23
He's deferring 97% of his contract for an entire decade, perhaps I'm a bit of a conspiracy theorist on this one but deferring that much money for a decade to avoid CA state taxes only is ridiculous. The terms indicated there's no interest being earned on that derral so the $68MM he defers each year isn't growing, he also doesn't have the opportunity to invest that money elsewhere for an entire decade. The time value of that money being lost exceeds 10% in CA state taxes each year. I don't know what the tax situation is if he retires and goes straight back to Japan in a decade at the conclusion of the contract, perhaps that adds up. To me this feels like a way to defer compensation that will specifically become an ownership interest when his playing days are over.
9:44a, 12/12/23
In reply to Max Power
Supposedly he earns another $50M or so annually outside of baseball (whatever the actual number is it is significant). So he can defer some money and still get by on his $50M, plus the $2M each year from the Dodgers.
Max Power said:
He's deferring 97% of his contract for an entire decade, perhaps I'm a bit of a conspiracy theorist on this one but deferring that much money for a decade to avoid CA state taxes only is ridiculous. The terms indicated there's no interest being earned on that derral so the $68MM he defers each year isn't growing, he also doesn't have the opportunity to invest that money elsewhere for an entire decade. The time value of that money being lost exceeds 10% in CA state taxes each year. I don't know what the tax situation is if he retires and goes straight back to Japan in a decade at the conclusion of the contract, perhaps that adds up. To me this feels like a way to defer compensation that will specifically become an ownership interest when his playing days are over.
Supposedly he earns another $50M or so annually outside of baseball (whatever the actual number is it is significant). So he can defer some money and still get by on his $50M, plus the $2M each year from the Dodgers.
11:10a, 12/12/23
He makes about $40 mil per year in endorsements.
Here is a good article on why the contract makes sense for both sides: https://www.cbssports.com/mlb/news/shohei-ohtani-contract-explaining-the-massive-680-million-deferral-why-it-benefits-both-ohtani-and-dodgers/#:~:text=This%20past%20season%2C%20Ohtani%20made,salary%20the%20Angels%20paid%20him.
Here is a good article on why the contract makes sense for both sides: https://www.cbssports.com/mlb/news/shohei-ohtani-contract-explaining-the-massive-680-million-deferral-why-it-benefits-both-ohtani-and-dodgers/#:~:text=This%20past%20season%2C%20Ohtani%20made,salary%20the%20Angels%20paid%20him.
1:48p, 12/12/23
Listen to the audio
The Dodgers after deferring $680 million of Ohtani’s contract til 2034
— Barstool Sports (@barstoolsports) December 12, 2023
(Via @JFrankensteiner )
pic.twitter.com/SATt58psXk
4:05p, 12/12/23
So, just hypothetically speaking here...what happens if the Dodgers were to go bankrupt in the span of 10 years? The deferred payouts could really bite SO in the ass, right?
7:31p, 12/12/23
In reply to crowman2010
crowman2010 said:
So, just hypothetically speaking here...what happens if the Dodgers were to go bankrupt in the span of 10 years? The deferred payouts could really bite SO in the ass, right?
One of the biggest misconceptions about Shohei Ohtani's contract is that the Dodgers will have an additional ten years to pay him the money.
— Joe Pompliano (@JoePompliano) December 12, 2023
But that's not how it works.
Major League Baseball's CBA requires teams to fully fund the present-day value of deferred payments within…
7:59p, 12/12/23
In reply to Panama Red
Good lord those ticket prices
Avg. Ticket Prices (Before & After Ohtani)
Opening Day: $474 to $811 (+74%)
All Home Games: $327 to $482 (+47%)
Avg. Ticket Prices (Before & After Ohtani)
Opening Day: $474 to $811 (+74%)
All Home Games: $327 to $482 (+47%)
8:37p, 12/12/23
In reply to Panama Red
There is a luxury tax advantage for the Dodgers also, that he doesn't mention in that tweet.Panama Red said:crowman2010 said:
So, just hypothetically speaking here...what happens if the Dodgers were to go bankrupt in the span of 10 years? The deferred payouts could really bite SO in the ass, right?One of the biggest misconceptions about Shohei Ohtani's contract is that the Dodgers will have an additional ten years to pay him the money.
— Joe Pompliano (@JoePompliano) December 12, 2023
But that's not how it works.
Major League Baseball's CBA requires teams to fully fund the present-day value of deferred payments within…
6:33p, 12/13/23
In reply to double aught
What's the luxury tax advantage? That the luxury tax hit is based on the NPV of the contract?
5:05p, 1/16/24
In reply to themissinglink
I inadvertently lost track of this thread. So, to answer your question: I don't remember.